December Daily: Looking back on Harry Potter

cesperanza, "I'll ask an HP question, actually, because I wasn't really ever in it and I'm interested in the reactions of people who were. It seems to me from the outside so spectacularly meh now; like, it was the fictional equiv of Lost (which I also didn't watch) where it was fascinating as a piece of serialized fiction but where the execution simply couldn't live up to the collective imagination. Am I wrong?"

Well, you're not wrong ... but "fascinating as a piece of serialized fiction but where the execution simply couldn't live up to the collective imagination" is just another way of saying "Fanbait."

I mean, Shatner-era Star Trek -- the classic fandom inspiration -- would you say it could live up to the collective imagination? Would you be eager to watch it today if the Trek universe in your mind didn't include the fanworks as well as the canon?

Maybe you'd have a lot of writers and directors saying, "I remembered it fondly from childhood, and then I went back and watched it again ... and it inspired me to create things that were actually as good as what I remembered."

So. Harry Potter. If I re-read Philosopher's Stone, Chamber of Secrets, and Prisoner of Azkaban, I expect that it would be a genuine pleasure. Goblet of Fire and Order of the Phoenix would be a mixed pleasure. I barely got through Half-Blood Prince and Deathly Hallows the first time.

On the other hand, the universe shows some cracks where the ethics weren't fully thought through, but every page is jam-packed with invention. The characters were sometimes shoehorned into going ways that they didn't want to go, but there are so many of them, and they're still alive.

I could open any book to a random page and start reading, and I'll bet I'd have a story idea within three pages. I might describe it as "here's something else JKR screwed up," but it would be a story idea!


schneefink, I moved your question earlier to make room for ride_4ever's birthday.

( Click for question list. 5 days left to fill. )