Trying to tell someone that their response of a story is incorrect is inappropriate.
Are you joking?
Look, if I write a piece of SGA fanfic and you tell me it's not a response to Stargate Atlantis, that is an incorrect statement. How is it inappropriate to tell you that you have made a factually incorrect statement, like "Helen's story is not a response to Xanthe's?" That's not a debatable opinion, it's just... completely wrong.
And I refuse to quit because you told me to.
Not because I told you to. Because (1) you said yourself that you missed the point of Helen's story, and (2) you keep making factually incorrect statements about it. Not just different opinions; *factually incorrect statements*, like 2+2=5.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
(no subject)
Date: 11/19/06 02:51 am (UTC)Trying to tell someone that their response of a story is incorrect is inappropriate.
Are you joking?
Look, if I write a piece of SGA fanfic and you tell me it's not a response to Stargate Atlantis, that is an incorrect statement. How is it inappropriate to tell you that you have made a factually incorrect statement, like "Helen's story is not a response to Xanthe's?" That's not a debatable opinion, it's just... completely wrong.
And I refuse to quit because you told me to.
Not because I told you to. Because (1) you said yourself that you missed the point of Helen's story, and (2) you keep making factually incorrect statements about it. Not just different opinions; *factually incorrect statements*, like 2+2=5.